In our newest Roguecast, we ran down the top five comics in various categories from managers Randy, Dave and Nick. Here are our Best Of lists, with a few extra places added in for Best New Series that just missed the top five cut.
Best New Series:
Dave:
1. Tuki
2. She-Hulk
3. Birthright
4. Storm
5. Magneto
Batgirl
Wytches
Sabrina
Spider-Man 2099
Nick:
1. Southern Bastards
2. She-Hulk
3. Birthright
4. Thor
5. Punisher
Ms. Marvel
Copperhead
Grayson
Randy:
1. Ms. Marvel
2. She-Hulk
3. Storm
4. Amazing Spider-Man
5. Punisher
The Spread
Spider-Man 2099
Wayward
Copperhead
Birthright
Batgirl
Best Ongoing Series:
Dave:
1. Daredevil
2. Afterlife with Archie
3. Alex + Ada
4. Sex Criminals
5. Star Wars
Nick:
1. East of West
2. Batman
3. Daredevil
4. Afterlife with Archie
5. Revival
Randy:
1. Saga
2. Sex Criminals
3. Daredevil
4. Afterlife with Archie
5. Alex + Ada
Best Mini-Series:
Dave:
1. Death of Wolverine
2. D&D Legends of Baldur’s Gate
3. Edge of Spider-Verse
Nick:
1. Multiversity
2. Death of Wolverine
3. Grendel vs. Shadow
4. Sandman Overture
5. The Wake
Randy:
1. Usagi Yojimbo Senso
2. Grendel vs. Shadow
3. D&D Legends of Baldur’s Gate
4. Edge of Spider-Verse
5. Scarlet Spiders
Best Original Graphic Novel:
Dave:
1. Through the Woods
2. Bryan Lee O’Malley’s Seconds
3. Costume Quest: Invasion of the Candy Snatchers
4. Rise of Aurora West
Nick:
1. Thanos Infinity Revelation
2. Rise of Aurora West
Randy:
1. Bryan Lee O’Malley’s Seconds
2. Little Nemo Dream Another Dream
3. Cleopatra in Space Vol 1
4. Rise of Aurora West
5. Amulet Vol 6
Best Collected Edition:
Dave:
1. Afterlife with Archie Vol 1
2. She-Hulk Vol 1
3. Velvet Vol 1
4. We3 New Edition
5. Ms. Marvel Vol 1
Nick:
1. Chew Omnivore HC Vol 4
2. Saga Vol 1 HC
3. Revival Vol 2 HC
4. Guardians of the Galaxy by Abnett & Lanning Vol 1
5. Runaways Vol 1-2
Randy:
1. Daredevil by Mark Waid Vol 2-3 HC
2. Saga Vol 1 HC
3. Ms. Marvel Vol 1
4. Afterlife with Archie Vol 1
5. Sex Criminals Vol 1
Best Writer:
Dave:
1. Charles Soule
2. Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa
3. Mark Waid
4. Sara Vaughn & Jonathan Luna
5. Matt Fraction
Nick:
1. Mark Waid
2. Grant Morrison
3. Charles Soule
4. Jonathan Hickman
5. Nathan Edmonson
Randy:
1. Brian K. Vaughan
2. Mark Waid
3. Dan Slott
4. Matt Fraction
5. Ed Brubaker
Best Artist:
Dave:
1. Emily Caroll
2. Babs Tarr
3. Javier Pulido
4. Francesco Francavilla
5. Chris Samnee
Nick:
1. Nick Dragotta
2. Chris Samnee
3. Ryan Stegman
4. Javier Pulido
5. Greg Capullo
Randy:
1. Chris Samnee
2. Adrian Alphona
3. Fiona Staples
4. Francesco Francavilla
5. Stan Sakai
